One member on the forum brought up a news story of a miracle that was attributed to Rendiles. Here's the article with some excerpts:

According to the Vatican, she miraculously cured a young woman diagnosed with a type of hydrocephalus, a condition in which cerebrospinal fluid builds up within the brain.

Her condition had worsened until a Mass was celebrated before Rendiles’ grave. Loved ones prayed for her recovery. And after the sick woman touched Rendiles’ portrait, her health improved.

“The young woman’s recovery was complete, stable and long-lasting, and the event was deemed scientifically inexplicable,” the Holy See said in a written statement.

I'm a bit skeptical but I'll leave this up for discussion.

For Discussion
Was this a genuine miracle? Why or why not?
 
Was this a genuine miracle? Why or why not?
I'm not convinced that this was a miracle. I Googled "Carmen Rendiles" and much of the information is all the same details that from the article I linked to in my last post. I would need more information but lets go off of what we have now.

For starters, I agree with the Catholic Church's explanation for what a miracle involves... (from the AP article)
“The young woman’s
recovery was complete, stable and long-lasting, and the event was deemed scientifically inexplicable,” the Holy See said in a written statement.

What I don't see evidence for is that God or Saint Carmen Rendiles were involved. I'm not sure of the exact date the alleged miracle took place, but the article makes it sound as though this was a recent event. Either way, we do know that the alleged miracle took place after Carmen Rendiles had died since it happened during a Mass celebration at the location of "Rendiles' grave".

Additional information I would want is the name of the person that was healed, when exactly it took place, and most importantly, more about her medical condition, and hopefully multiple and independent corroboration of medical doctors. If anyone has a source for any additional details, then please post it on the forum.

Another issue is how does this square with Christian theology. This story makes it seem as though it is Saint Rendiles that did the miracle. Isn't it God that heals? And how can someone heal another from beyond the grave? Is praying to a dead person even Biblical? 🤔
 
  • Like
Reactions: Multicolored Lemur
This story makes it seem as though it is Saint Rendiles that did the miracle. Isn't it God that heals?
God acting through the Saint?
Doesn't that break supernatural rule #145949?

All kidding aside. I guess it's possible. What got me was that this was more attributed to Carmen, or really just a picture of her, and not so much God. So then I can see that making people look to these things like idols. I mean I'm open to considering otherwise, but I do question how this aligns with the Bible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Multicolored Lemur
question how this aligns with the Bible.
There's a reasonable chance that the 4 Gospels, the Book of Acts, and the many letters say contradictory things about healing, don't you think? Or at least things which emphasize different aspects.
 
Mark says in a couple of places, that if you have enough faith, your child will be healed. I think that's running a real number on parents.

And there are other parts of the Bible that says God’s will and all in good time.

Miracles_from_Heaven_poster.jpg


the Christian movie “Miracles from Heaven” talks about some of this, from 2016
 
Mark says in a couple of places, that if you have enough faith, your child will be healed. I think that's running a real number on parents.

And there are other parts of the Bible that says God’s will and all in good time.
This was a tricky one so I did some research before coming up with my view.

I was looking for passages and remembered Jesus talking about even a small amount of faith being able to move mountains and trees (example, Luke 17:6). If we're dealing in theology though, we can't take those passages in isolation to get an understanding, but rather look for all relevant passages to form a coherent view. Of course, an exception would be if Luke 17:6 used explicit exclusionary language, like saying faith alone could move trees.

I also think reality comes into play here since it shows faith alone doesn't work when we have many devout Christians who were never healed, including the Apostle Paul himself (2 Corinthians 12:7-9)...
7 or because of these surpassingly great revelations. Therefore, in order to keep me from becoming conceited, I was given a thorn in my flesh, a messenger of Satan, to torment me. 8 Three times I pleaded with the Lord to take it away from me.

Still, there are stories of Christian relics that are said to heal (Shroud of Turin?), and then there's the story of the woman who touched Jesus's robe and got healed (Mark 5:25-34). Jesus clearly said "her faith made her well" (Mark 5:34). But I do wonder if God is implied in that passage since by definition faith is belief in something (God, for instance). Wouldn't make sense to say her faith was in faith itself. Also, mentions that Jesus's power being involved Mark 5:30 which is something different than faith.

Mark 5:25-34 -
25 A woman who had had a hemorrhage for twelve years, 26 and had endured much at the hands of many physicians, and had spent all that she had and was not helped at all, but instead had become worse— 27 after hearing about Jesus, she came up in the crowd behind Him and touched His cloak. 28 For she had been saying to herself, “If I just touch His garments, I will get well.” 29 And immediately the flow of her blood was dried up; and she felt in her body that she was healed of her disease. 30 And immediately Jesus, perceiving in Himself that power from Him had gone out, turned around in the crowd and said, “Who touched My garments?” 31 And His disciples said to Him, “You see the crowd pressing in on You, and You say, ‘Who touched Me?’” 32 And He looked around to see the woman who had done this. 33 But the woman, fearing and trembling, aware of what had happened to her, came and fell down before Him and told Him the whole truth. 34 And He said to her, “Daughter, your faith has made you well; go in peace and be cured of your disease.”