bbyrd009
“I don’t know anything. Ever…” DGently
i gotta admit that that one is strange. It doesnt seem to have any direct witness, and infers that we have souls rather than being souls. If the Greek for breath is rendered as soul, then how can that be? idkJust a sum up of my view after reading both sides, i.e. Hell is eternal punishment vs. Hell is temporary punishment.
For now, I lean towards Hell being a place for eternal punishment for those that are not believers. I'm not 100% sold on that view only because of passages, like Matthew 25:28 that talk about the soul being destroyed.
“eternal” translated from aionos, a space of time, an age, rather than aidios, foreverThe evidence for the word "destroy" not being literal wasn't convincing after having a second look at it so that's my only lingering doubt about the eternal punishment view. Matthew 25:46 specifically referring to believers going away to eternal punishment sealed the deal for me. Because it doesn't just say non-believers will be thrown in Hell. Had it said that alone, then there might be room to say that they can be "destroyed" in the fire. But the Matt. 25:46 passage clearly says "eternal punishment". That would also be consistent with its parallel of "eternal life", unless someone wants to argue why "eternal life" literally means living in Paradise forever, while "eternal punishment" in the same context doesn't mean forever.
then imo you have to reconcile All go to the same place, No one has ever gone up to heaven, There is only One Immortal, etcFinally, there's the view that the word Hell in the Bible really refers to Gehenna. It is a compelling argument. I do agree that at times the word "Hell" in the Bible refers to Gehenna. But, there are times when the Bible gives a description of "eternal punishment" , and in that case you don't even need the label Hell. In that case, it's a matter of matching the description with a label, and "eternal punishment" does not equal Gehenna.
Therefore, eternal punishment is the most likely valid view.
Thanks for all the input!
Last edited: